On retirement, insured persons decide whether to draw their retirement assets as a lifelong annuity, as a one-off lump sum or as a combination. According to a report in the NZZ, more than half of men and around one third of women now draw their pension assets wholly or partly as a lump sum. The decision is generally irrevocable and should therefore be prepared carefully.
Legal framework
Insured persons can draw at least one quarter of their BVG retirement assets as a lump sum (Art. 37 para. 2 BVG). Whether a higher proportion is possible and by when the lump-sum withdrawal must be notified is determined by the pension fund’s regulations. For married persons and registered partners, the written consent of the spouse or registered partner is required (Art. 37a BVG).
Taxation
The annuity is taxed in full each year together with other income. The lump sum, by contrast, is taxed separately from other income at a reduced rate, at federal level at one fifth of the ordinary rate (Art. 38 DBG). Cantonal rules differ considerably. Anyone who has made buy-ins to the pension fund in the three years before the withdrawal may not draw the resulting benefits as a lump sum (Art. 79b para. 3 BVG).
Weighing up the options
The annuity provides a guaranteed lifelong income and covers the longevity risk. On the death of the insured person, however, any remaining capital generally passes to the pension fund unless survivors’ benefits are owed. The lump sum offers flexibility, for example to amortise a mortgage or for estate planning. In return, you bear the investment risk and the risk that the assets are used up before the end of your life.
Basis for the decision
Relevant factors include the pension fund’s conversion rate, the expected tax burden of both options, other income and assets, health and family circumstances. A calculation of both options over the expected lifetime provides the basis for a well-founded decision.
Calculate annuity or lump sum
We calculate both options for your situation, including the tax consequences.
Request a consultation →
Question about this article?